Supply Chain Lab Supply Contract Lab Lab Home
Procurement & Contracts

Supply Contract Lab: Double Marginalization

A manufacturer and a retailer, one newsvendor season. Under a plain wholesale price the retailer orders too little - double marginalization - and the chain leaves money on the table. Tune a buyback or revenue-share and watch the efficiency gauge climb back to 100%.

How to use it

The contract lab

Market

Contract levers

–
q: integrated / wholesale
–
Wholesale efficiency
–
Buyback efficiency

Chain profit as the wholesale price changes. The dashed navy line is the integrated benchmark Π*; the gap under any w is double marginalization. Your current w is marked.

Same pie, four ways to split it: manufacturer, retailer, and the grey slice is profit lost to the chain versus Π*. Coordinating contracts erase the grey.

Chain coordination - buyback

–

Try these experiments

  1. Push wholesale price w up to maximise the manufacturer's profit alone, and watch chain efficiency drop - the manufacturer gains but the pie shrinks.
  2. Set the buyback b to the coordinating value shown in the hint - efficiency hits 100% and the grey "lost" slice vanishes.
  3. Now match it with revenue share φ: a different split, but the buyback and revenue-share contracts reach the same coordinated chain profit.

About this tool

The concept

When each firm marks up in turn, the retailer's order-up-to point falls short of what maximises the whole chain - double marginalization.

How it works

The retailer orders to a critical fractile against its own overage/underage costs; contracts reshape those costs to restore the integrated order.

Winning strategy

Coordinate the chain: buyback and revenue-sharing can both hit 100% efficiency; they differ only in how the recovered profit is divided between the firms.